THE NATIONAL - Alligator (2005), listen #2

I started my second play of Alligator on a night when I was stressed out and frustrated, and did so right after listening to Wall Of Eyes, the new record by the Smile.  With the latter record, there were a lot of repetitious guitar and keyboard phrases designed to put the listener in a state, and even though I don’t actually like the way Tom York* sings all that much, I immediately felt willing to give the songs some time and repeat listens to grow on me.  That juxtaposition of the those two records highlighted how much the National are also that sort of band sometimes, or try to be.  It’s been that way since the first record, but that element seems especially pronounced on Alligator.  Most songs start with a guitar-forward track that functions almost like a loop and then plays continuously through the song, building a mood to take the listener into a headspace over which Matt, often tunelessly, weaves in his stories.  This is basically my latest attempt to describe coherently what “indie-rock” sounds like to me, and why I lump the National in with that sound. 

I can see a few of these choruses wearing me down through sheer power and repetition and getting me humming them.  At the moment the biggest earworms I’ve been getting are the chorus of “All The Wine,” which is fine, and the “that man’s a balloon” part from “Friend Of Mine,” which, eh, is slightly annoying.  Again, this is all stuff they’ve been doing since the self-titled debut.  The hook from “American Mary” still frequently pops up in my head, although I can’t say I ever especially need to hear the song again.

Some things that I wish did lodge in my head were a few favorite bits.  Because Alligator is tantalizingly full of individual notes or phrases that I really, really like, making we wish the rest of the songs were like that.  As an exercise, I decided to try to list out from memory the things that made me think “this part is great,” and I know I’m only remembering about half of them:
 - There’s a part in “Secret Meeting” where the vocal melody goes up while the guitar line goes down, and for those fifteen seconds or so everything just clicks
-  The first verse of “Daughters Of The Soho [SoHo?] Riots” – it embodies total resignation and hopelessness in a pretty beautiful way
- The paired vocals at certain particular parts of “Val Jester,” I don’t remember which ones
- The delivery of “c’mon, give me the keys, man” in “Abel.”  The whole song is pretty dope, actually, full of nervous energy.  I doubt it’s actually what it’s about, but I like to imagine that the narrator is clumsily trying to cover up a murder.
- The way when you listen to the record in order, the end of “Abel” melts into the quiet opening of “The Geese Of Beverly Road”
-  In “Mr. November,” the way the Bryan takes over the song and moves us so nicely into and through the last prechorus.  (And I kinda like the way that one just stops so suddenly after its abbreviated final chorus.)
 
That’s a partial list, because Alligator’s bits are standing out to me more than the tracks as a whole.  These bits have me pretty well convinced that, if they choose to, the National are capable of making a record that I’ll really love.  I’m also pretty well convinced that Alligator is not that record.  But it’s worth another spin or two to see which parts grow on me. 
 
As a final note, after my second listen to Alligator, which I finished on another night on which I was stressed and frustrated, I switched to a record by a doom band called Sorcerer and immediately said “fuck yeah, this is what I want to listen to when I’m frustrated.”  I feel like that says something or other about my tastes overall.
 
- Favorite track:  “Abel”
- Runner up: “Mr. November”
- Least favorite track:  “City Middle”
- Working rating:  2.5/5
 
Listen #3 whenever I get around to it!
 

*With internet space being at a premium in the post internet freedom era, my blog does not have the resources to include unnecessary letters in singers’ names.** 

**Joke stolen from David Thorpe at the old Something Awful website

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ELUVEITIE - Slania (2008)

I wasn’t so thrilled with my writeup of Spirit , but perhaps it was appropriate for something I was still trying to get a handle on and understand.   I return with my second review of the band returning with their second record, and this time hopefully I can spend less time listing individual elements of songs and more conveying how it makes me feel to listen to them.   We shall see.   Now the band has eight members rather than nine, and this is the first record to feature then eighteen-year-old Anna Murphy on hurdy-gurdy and backing vocals.   So now we have the pieces in place for the eventual Cellar Darling split.   Whoever is operating the instruments, though, I think Eluveitie is absolutely and thoroughly  Chrigel ’s band at this point.   I imagined we’d see Merlin and Ivo (and Anna, I guess) getting progressively more writing credits as we stepped through the discography.   Apparently not, though, or at least not yet.    Chrigel...
Read more

B-FEST 2024: Just remember - don't do drugs, because B-Fest may just rip your face off

  I've chosen to primarily nerd out about music on this here blog.   But once a year, I channel my energies into an annual celebration of bad and weird cinema at B-Fest, a 24+-hour B-movie marathon that I've been attending almost continually since 2004.  The event happens in the Norris student center on the Northwestern University campus and draws basically a small self-selecting group of weirdos who think it's fun to watch weird movies in a group setting.  I try to compile my thoughts and recollections. Lest anyone think that the fact that I'm not actually much of a movie person could lead me to not take this event seriously, I'll note that I was at a meeting in Colorado that I only signed up to go to once clear that it wouldn't conflict with B-Fest, and I got up at 0545 missing the last few talks on Fri morning specifically so I could go to B-Fest.  And further, when my flight from Denver was delayed six hours such that I'd miss the first few hours of ...
Read more

ELUVEITIE - Ategnatos (2019)

Finally getting around to this.  We're back in metal-land with the new guys and gals fully incorporated into the band.  Sticking with the reported spirit of collaboration, Jonas Wolf (again - JONAS. WOLF.  Still such a metal name...) is credited with production help and gets just tons of songwriting credits, including getting listed before Chrigel on occasion.  Most of the others pitch in here and there too as co-writers, but it's mostly Chrigel and Jonas.  Here's what they come up with on the band's longest release to date. Track One:  "Ategnatos" Oh great, more Andrew narration.  At least it's brief.  An appealing flute figure that'll pop up a few times on this record * (and in our first bit of "this sounds like that other song," it sounds a lot like the tune also used as the basis for "The Nameless" - no wonder I keep wanting to sing "holy father in darkness" instead of the actual lyrics) leads us into an appealing Fab...
Read more