"Classic" of metal: HELLOWEEN - Chameleon (1993), upon further review

The big question I posted in the "early impressions" post was how Chameleon as a whole could be explained.  It's not Helloween sounding like Helloween, and sure as hell doesn't sound commercial.  I tried thinking of it as a Michael Kiske solo record rather than a Helloween record, which sorta made sense, except he's often sidelined for minutes at a time, and oh, look, here comes a reworking of one of Roland Grapow's old songs from ten years earlier.  I probably should have just read more band comments, in which case I would've quickly gotten to Michael himself calling it three different guys' solo albums butting up against each other.  So, that's why there's not a coherent vibe or theme.  Just five years removed from Helloween pushing the boundaries of speed/power with a coherent vision in which all members appeared to be totally on the same page, Chameleon is a bunch of songs that try to further expand the band's scope, but this time without any apparent agreement on how to actually do so.  There was no unifying vision, which is why I don't hear one.
 
So, say we've established that.  Say we're able to forget expectations of what a Helloween record "should" be, and we just sit down and listen to Chameleon as a collection of unrelated individual pieces.  Are these good songs?  For the most part, no, they're not.  (In my opinion, obviously.  I don't like them very much).  There's a hodgepodge of reasons for why, with each specimen being different, although one general theme is that near every damn one is longer than it needs to be.
 
"First Time" rocks on some level and has a nicely wordy chorus.  But in part I'm just not a fan of the big dumb '70/'80s glam-inspired style in general, and I absolutely cannot get past the cringeworthy lyrics whenever I try to let go and just go with it.  Michael's performance is particularly flat, like he's unwilling or unable to commit to playing the role of endearingly sleazy seducer.  By the time the last chorus rolls around, I am so ready to be done with the song.  "When The Sinner" is at least something different, failing more due to overambition than under.  It's the first of multiple songs on the record to use a pulsating background beat of the sort that at different times in rock history has been in vogue*... and then it throws horns on top of it for some reason, and a pre-chorus that I don't like at all with the two vocal parts stepping on each other, and then back to a slow groove for an okay chorus.  Why is this the one that busts out a traditional guitar solo?  Why is this one nearly seven minutes long when so much of it is dedicated to repetition?  I'm already exhausted.  And so on.  I considered going through the record track by track to dive into exactly where each piece goes astray, but I don't think it would make for very interesting writing, because I find actually listening to most of these songs to be a deeply tedious experience.  Some are crap songs that're too long, some are potentially interesting ideas that're too long, and some are mishmashes of competing elements that're too long.  Even "Crazy Cat," a fun enough lark, is too long for what it is.  Even "Step Out Of Hell," owner of the record's most memorable chorus, is a little too slow-paced to live up to its full potential.  I got tired of listening to these in almost record time.  For a band whose whole thing is melodic sophistication and mastery of the art of the hook, the scarcity of quality earworms is remarkable.  The parts that do stick I find pretty annoying.  I never want to hear the chorus of "Windmill" again, or eight-plus minutes of that tedious "Revolution Now" riff and its equally tedious chorus ever again.**
 
As a showcase for Michael as a vocalist, I think his limitations are exposed.  That's part of why even if I try to strip away the notoriety of the names "Helloween" and Chameleon and instead imagine that I'm writing a review of Shapeshifter, the debut release from The Michael Kiske Band, it's not a very positive review.  I argued in last time I wrote about Helloween that he's more of a good metal singer than an actual good singer, such that he has a few specific tricks he does well that make his voice go very well with a loud, busy, band.  Here on "Shapeshifter," there are more slower and sparser numbers that he really has to carry, doing lyrical songs without being able to lean into the metal scream.  "The Michael Kiske Band" don't usually try to recreate what Helloween did on "A Tale That Wasn't Right" back on Keeper Of The Seven Keys, probably for the best.  I've successfully so far avoided attempting to explain why "A Tale That Wasn't Right" works, so now I have to face the fact that I'm not good enough of a music writer to explain why ATTWR works.  Because "logically" that song shouldn't work.  Michael's shifting between a simple sparse tune and a hair-metal croon should read as impossibly cheesy.  Best I can come up with, ATTWR is deceptively tightly written, with very precise and crisp starts and stops, exactly the right number of trailing guitar notes, plus it benefits from being "the" ballad, the only real slow song on a relatively short and speedy record.  Well, whatever secret sauce was involved, it's in short supply on the slow songs here.  Michael is left to use pure lyrical-style singing to carry some pretty straightforward melodies.  He sounds pedestrian.  Passable, but doing little to really sell or elevate the material.
 
Like most "bad" songs from talented artists, almost everything on Chameleon has the kernel of something good that's sabotaged either by pairing it with something I don't like or by being underbaked to start with.  I mean, it's not like Weiki, Markus, Roland, or Ingo has forgotten how to play, so of course they're going to stumble upon something nice here and there.  I was rather surprised to find, after I hadn't listened to Helloween in days, the chorus of "In The Night" was frequently getting into my head.  I like the combination of the rolling almost rockabilly guitar and the bursts of bass and R.E.M.-esque keys to support the rolling melody.  I'm not convinced that the song is a success, and the vocal part is pretty boring, but at worst, it's an interesting near-miss rather than a boring one.  
 
Also like most "bad" records by talented enough acts, there's that one song where they do actually get it right and make me wonder if I'm misjudging them.  For me, the contractually obligated "good" song here is "I Believe."  Hey, here's Helloween progressing logically from one musical idea to another*** just like they used to.  They're taking advantage of having two guitarists the way they used to.  Michael is actually using both his mid and high ranges with conviction like he used to, and it's in the service of fairly thoughtful lyrics.  That "I wanna love but I always hate" part does a build-up so insistent and relentless that I'd believe you if you told me that Kai Hansen ghostwrote it.  How did this particular reminder of Helloween's potential happen exactly once?  And why did it happen in a song that was (actually) written by Mr. Kiske, the member of Helloween who was most actively and obviously trying to get out of the power metal game?  The world may never know. 
 
I'd like to go listen to something else now.
 
 
Favorite track:  "I Believe"
Runner up:  "In The Night"
Least favorite track:  "Revolution Now"
Rating:  1.5/5 
 
*comparisons I considered making at different times include: early '80s new-wave; Rick Derringer; White Zombie.
 
**The band's inability to get enough things right at the same time really rears its head here.  I know I mentioned this in the first post, but can I marvel again at how mismatched the pointed and, well, angry lyrics from the verse of "Revolution Now" are with the bland funk-rock riff and limp chorus? 
 
***In typical Helloween epic fashion, "I Believe" has elements of prog without quite drifting over wherever that invisible line is to actually become prog-metal.  Less of a complex song structure so much as a standard song structure with an extended middle section. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

?Classics? of power metal #13: JUDICATOR - At The Expense Of Humanity (2015), early impressions

WARREN ZEVON - Sentimental Hygiene (1987)

?Classics? of power metal #6: AVANTASIA - The Metal Opera (2001), upon further review